logo

Those who read this Blog know that it isn’t easy to avoid a written settlement or release agreement after it is duly executed.  See, e.g., Challenging Releases and Settlements Based on Fraudulent Inducement is a Challenge.

The leading New York Court of Appeals decision remains Centro Empresarial Cempresa S.A. v América Móvil, S.A.B. de C.V., 17 NY3d 269 (2011), which sets the framework as follows:

Generally, “a valid release constitutes a complete bar to an action on a claim [*5]which is the subject of the release” (Global Mins. & Metals Corp. v Holme, 35 AD3d 93, 98 [1st Dept 2006]). If “the language of a release is clear and unambiguous, the signing of a release is a ‘jural act’ binding on the parties” (Booth v 3669 Delaware, 92 NY2d 934, 935 [1998], quoting Mangini v McClurg, 24 NY2d 556, 563 [1969]). A release “should never be converted into a starting point for . . . litigation except under circumstances and under rules which would render any other result a grave injustice” (Mangini, 24 NY2d at 563). A release may be invalidated, however, for any of “the traditional bases for setting aside written agreements, namely, duress, illegality, fraud, or mutual mistake” (id.).

Although a defendant has the initial burden of establishing that it has been released from any claims, a signed release “shifts the burden of going forward . . . to the [plaintiff] to show that there has been fraud, duress or some other fact which will be sufficient to void the release” (Fleming v Ponziani, 24 NY2d 105, 111 [1969]). A plaintiff seeking to invalidate a release due to fraudulent inducement must “establish the basic elements of fraud, namely a representation of material fact, the falsity of that representation, knowledge by the party who made the representation that it was false when made, justifiable reliance by the plaintiff, and resulting injury” (Global Mins., 35 AD3d at 98).

While courts do wish to respect and promote the finality of the resolution of disputes by agreement of the parties, they also recognize the mischief and harm that can by caused by fraudulent conduct.  Thus, as the Court of Appeals observed in Centro, settlements and releases can be avoided where they are the product of fraudulent inducement.

The recent decision of the Appellate Division, Fourth Department, in Robert Basil Motors, Inc. v Ball, 2026 NY Slip Op 06632 (4th Dep’t Decided Nov. 13, 2026) is a classic blueprint of fraudulent inducement.

Case Foundation

The foundation of the Ball case was an asset purchase transaction in which confidential information and goodwill were part of the purchased assets.  Plaintiffs purchased the assets of defendant’s car dealership and entered into employment and confidentiality agreements with defendant, pursuant to which plaintiffs employed defendant as a salesperson. After defendant’s employment, plaintiffs sued defendant alleging he diverted business to his new employer by making use of confidential information that he had either sold to plaintiffs as goodwill or acquired through his employment with plaintiffs. Defendant asserted counterclaims arising from plaintiffs’ alleged failure to pay bonus commissions.

The parties arrived at a settlement agreement, “in which defendant represented and warranted that he was not ‘in possession of any of [plaintiffs’] proprietary and/or confidential information, . . . copies or originals of any documents reflecting the goodwill’ sold by defendant, or ‘any information copied from, or extracted from, any documents reflecting’ that goodwill.”  Defendant was able to continue his counterclaims.

Then, in discovery relating to the counterclaims, plaintiffs uncovered thousands of pages of documents that plaintiffs considered to be their “proprietary and/or confidential information,” as well as information extracted from the goodwill sold by defendant.  Upon this revelation, plaintiffs moved to set aside the settlement agreement, alleging defendant fraudulently induced them to enter into it and give up their claims in reliance on defendants (now allegedly false) representations that he had no such information.

The lower court denied plaintiffs’ motion. On appeal, the Fourth Department threw out the settlement agreement based upon fraudulent inducement and reinstated the complaint against defendant.

Fraud Eviscerates the Settlement

The Fourth Department began its analysis with the basic rules on attacking settlements:

“As with a contract, courts should not disturb a valid stipulation absent a showing of good cause such as fraud, collusion, mistake or duress” (McCoy v Feinman, 99 NY2d 295, 302 [2002]; see Hallock v State of New York, 64 NY2d 224, 230 [1984]). A party “seeking to invalidate a release due to fraudulent inducement must ‘establish the basic elements of fraud, namely a representation of material fact, the falsity of that representation, knowledge by the party who made the representation that it was false when made, justifiable reliance by the [party seeking to invalidate the release], and resulting injury’ ” (Centro Empresarial Cempresa S.A. v América Móvil, S.A.B. de C.V., 17 NY3d 269, 276 [2011]). Plaintiffs bore the burden on their motion (see Matter of Yehle v Rich, 188 AD3d 1656, 1657 [4th Dept 2020]; see also Hallock, 64 NY2d at 230) of establishing the elements of fraud “by clear and convincing evidence” (Simcuski v Saeli, 44 NY2d 442, 453 [1978]; see Mooney v Manhattan Occupational, Physical & Speech Therapies, PLLC, 166 AD3d 957, 960 [2d Dept 2018]; Richman v Albert, 127 AD2d 992, 992 [4th Dept 1987], lv denied 70 NY2d 745 [1987]).

The Court first had to address the issue of whether the discovery uncovered actually constituted confidential and proprietary information as encompassed within the contractual representations and warranties, because the lower court ruled they were not.  The Fourth Department applied the common dictionary meaning to those words and found that the discovery did qualify as such.

Once that factual representation was found to be false, the fraudulent inducement claim followed neatly.  One point of note here—the representation that defendant made was precisely one of fact, that he did not then possess the confidential and propriety information.  So that is the type of factual statement that is the classic foundation for a claim of fraud.  The twist here (which the Court did not otherwise comment upon) was that the representation was actually contained in the settlement agreement itself. I have addressed this issue often—the fact that a contractual representation can in fact be the basis of a separate claim for fraud.  See Representations and Warranties in LLC Buyout Contract Save Fraud Claim.

The Fourth Department ruled that all the elements of fraudulent inducement had been proved:

We thus conclude that plaintiffs established both the materiality and falsity of defendant’s representation in the settlement agreement that he was not in possession of any of plaintiffs’ proprietary or confidential information (see generally Centro Empresarial Cempresa S.A., 17 NY3d at 276). We further conclude that plaintiffs established that the representation was known by defendant to be untrue when made (see generally id.), or that it was at least ” ‘recklessly made’ ” (Golobe v Mielnicki, 44 NY3d 86, 92 [2025], rearg denied 43 NY3d 1013 [2025]); that plaintiffs were justified in relying on the representation without further inquiry (see generally Centro Empresarial Cempresa S.A., 17 NY3d at 276; DDJ Mgt., LLC v Rhone Group L.L.C., 15 NY3d 147, 154 [2010]); and that they were damaged by the false representation inasmuch as they were induced to give up their claim against defendant (see generally Centro Empresarial Cempresa S.A., 17 NY3d at 276; Cain-Henry v Shot, 194 AD3d 1465, 1466-1467 [4th Dept 2021]; Ford v Phillips, 121 AD3d 1232, 1235 [3d Dept 2014]). We therefore modify the order by granting the motion insofar as it seeks to set aside the settlement agreement and reinstate the complaint against defendant.

Commentary

While agreed-upon settlements are respected by the courts, fraud is always the basis to attack any contract, including any agreement to resolve or release claims.  A party seeking to avoid a settlement agreement does have the burden of establishing the grounds to disregard that agreement, including by adequately alleging and proving (by clear and convincing evidence) each of the elements of fraud.  The Fourth Department’s decision in Ball provides a classic roadmap for alleging and establishing fraudulent inducement sufficient to set aside a settlement agreement.

ALL THIS AND MORE

Meyer-Suozzi-White-Logo-Full-NEW-2

CONTACT US